Skip to content
All articles

Orphan Wells

What actually happens at a mandatory pre-bid meeting

3 MIN READ

Shawn Azdam

Founder

Pale gold morning light over teal contours with a small pumpjack silhouette.
On this page

February and March are pre-bid season: Ohio's county packages hold site-visit meetings through the winter, and Kentucky's spring awards wave means weeks of mandatory gatherings at wellheads across the state. For first-time bidders, the pre-bid is a mystery wrapped in a clipboard. This is what actually happens, and how to get your money's worth from the drive out.

The format: walk, talk, record

Most plugging pre-bids follow the same shape. The group meets at a designated point — often the well site itself, sometimes a county office for multi-site packages — and walks the work: access roads, wellheads, staging areas, neighbors. The owner's representative narrates scope highlights and known hazards. Then comes open Q&A, where bidders ask everything from the penetrating to the seemingly obvious.

The critical mechanic: answers given at the pre-bid are only binding if captured in writing afterward. Good owners issue written meeting minutes or fold the answers into an addendum; the answers then become part of the contract record that all bidders share. Anything said in the field and never written down is conversation, not contract. Take your own notes, then check them against the published minutes — and if the minutes omit something material that was said aloud, submit it as a written question yourself.

Why mandatory means mandatory

When a packet says attendance is mandatory, believe it. Owners use the requirement for two legitimate reasons: ensuring every bidder has seen the actual site conditions (which suppresses the "differing site conditions" change orders that plague blind bids), and creating a level information playing field where no bidder wins on private knowledge. Ohio's practice of meeting at the wellhead — Allen 6F convened at the Johnny Appleseed 3 site in late February — is the gold standard: you cannot misunderstand access you have driven yourself.

Disqualification for absence is real and generally not appealable. The sign-in sheet is a responsiveness criterion like any other. If two mandatory pre-bids collide on your calendar, that is a business development problem to solve with staffing, not with hope.

The questions that matter

Ask about what the packet cannot show you. Access under load: will the road hold a rig after rain, and who decides? Utilities and water: where does the frac tank fill, and who pays? Neighbors: which landowners have signed access, and which are still negotiating? Seasonal constraints: is there a window after which the site closes? And the all-important meta-question: will answers to today's questions be published in writing, and when?

Watch your competitors' questions as closely as the answers. A rival asking detailed fluid-disposal questions has spotted something in the scope you may have missed. Pre-bids are intelligence events in both directions — which is why experienced estimators send their sharpest people, not whoever is free.

After the meeting

The pre-bid ends; the work begins. File your written questions within days, while the site is fresh — most programs set a question deadline a week or two out, and late questions go unanswered. Reconcile what you saw against the scope section: every discrepancy between the packet and the field is either a question to file or a risk to price. And update your go/no-go: a site visit kills more bad bids than any estimating model, because some problems are only visible from the driver's seat of your truck.

What we think at Terrabillion

The mandatory pre-bid is the best procurement institution in plugging and the least appreciated. It forces owners to expose their scopes to daylight, forces bidders to confront reality before pricing, and generates a written record that protects both sides. Programs that waive site visits to save time borrow trouble at high interest. Our position is simple: if the package is worth bidding, it is worth visiting — and any owner who disagrees should expect the change orders they have earned.

Orphan-well intel, monthly

Contact sales